14
« on: January 24, 2008, 10:23:01 AM »
I'm normally a lurker on this site, but I logged in to respond to this message. Frist of all, I might come off as bias because I was a psychology major turned antipsychiatry, so I personally don't believe in the existence of bipolar (no proof of any mental illness other than what neurologists have discovered). However, when I first started to study psychology, it occured to me that Olga, in our modern times, might have been labeled bipolar. Especially given that it's become a very trendy diagnosis in the industry. No, you don't have to exhibit extreme behaviors in these days.
Personally, I think Olga's "condition" was the result of being incredibly smart and sensitive to her surroundings. For example, what prompted her break down? Working as a nurse, which is something that someone as sensitive as Olga shouldn't have had to do. Moreover, she seemed to understand Russia's political situation much better than her parents, or so I've read.
As for Alix, I think the same can be said of her. Given that she had four daughters, one right after the other, and endured years of stress trying to give birth to a boy, it's no wonder she was stressed! That and the fact that she didn't seem to be physically healthy all that often...