Leonid Sednev

[Dust_of_History]

Although it is not clear when, where and how he died, I can assure you that he did not die on the same spot where the IF died! Never heard of that story.

[aleksandr pavlovich]

Re:  Your Reply # 297: "Dust_of_History", also see my comments of Sept. 09, #211, "Having Fun!/ Re Reincarnations of the Romanovs."    Regards,  AP.

[LifeOfJudaism]

" Oh, the holocaust, killing over 6 million? no thats impossible, thats to many" Well it was possible, and it happened. Do you think it wil be hard to bring one boy back to yekaterinburg to the ipatiev house? you said that shawn had to have documented proof on what he beleives on leonid sednev. Wheres your documented proof that leonid DIDN'T die in the same place

[Dust_of_History]

I did not say it is impossible that Sednev died in Ekaterienburg. But he did not die on the same spot where the IF died. That would mean he died in the cellar room. There's no evidence that he was in Jekatierienburg after 1918.

[LifeOfJudaism]

There is also no evidence that he didn't. I believe this, you believe something else, i respect your belief, but idk if you will do of mine.

[LisaDavidson]

Yes, but beliefs are one thing, historical facts another. There is no evidence that Leshka Sednev was ever in Ekaterinburg after 1918. Period. So, as you have been directed on other threads, if your beliefs contradict facts, you must present evidence to support your belief.

And you evidence is? And please understand, I am seeking to learn here what may be unknown right now, so let's hear it.

[LifeOfJudaism]

Alright, i don't have any info that i didn't, so i am aware no one can believe me nor take me serious in this specific thing. But you also can't say he didn't, so right now, all we can say is, its unknown.

[aleksandr pavlovich]

Re Reply # 302: I obviously agree with you, Lisa, having researched and written a bit on this topic on this very thread.  It's obvious that we need to get beyond that subterfuge of the "I believe versus You believe" system and go with verifiable historical documentation. IMO, I feel that the poster to whom you addressed your Reply (also known elsewhere as "TheTinyJrLeshka"  ? ) has a none-too-subtle /reason/agenda to "push the point", but THAT belongs to ANOTHER board that caters to such a system of thought.  Hopefully this will be a helpful and positive learning experience for him.    Regards,  AP.  

[Dust_of_History]

I agree with Mr Davidson and AP. Somewhere here Nicola de Valeron posted an interview with Sednev's close relatives. If Sednev had died in Yekaterinburg, they definitely would have mentioned that, because this would have been quite remarkable. The theory Sednev died exactly on the same spot where the IF died is just false.

[LifeOfJudaism]

Maybe they would maybe they wouldn't, you can't say something is "false" or "true" just because something seemed likley to happen. Wherever Leonid Sednev died, would of been important, yet the relatives didn't say. All we can say, i repeat is, we just don't know yet

[Dust_of_History]

Yes, we do not know where exactly he died. But he did not die on the same spot where the IF died (which would mean the cellar room, at least that's how I understand the term "on the same spot"). His body was not found in the cellar room.

[LifeOfJudaism]

Well of course, if he did die in the celler, he would of been taken out and buried somewhere, like the imperial family. For all we know, it could of been feet or maybe even inches away from where they found the imperial family.

[Dust_of_History]

Well, there might be a possibility that he died somewhere around Yekaterinburg in one of the districts. But not in the Ipatiev House or nearby.

[LifeOfJudaism]

Well unless something was to prevent the murderers to enter the celler room in the ipatiev house, i stick to my word, but i guess we have to agree to disagree.

[Dust_of_History]

As long as you say that he might have died somewhere in the suburbs of Yekaterinburg, I say OK this could be. But he did not die in the Ipatiev House. That's just false.