I also frequent another board that has nothing to do with history, and the mods there always close and delete threads if they think an older one can be used. No matter how long or hard to load or out of date it is, they will not let you start a new one. So we should be very glad the mods here have been generous with us here. I think the problem that the same questions are being asked over and over and the same fights keep happening over and over have a lot to do with the mods wanting to condense here. Besides, someone somewhere must be paying for this site to stay up, and the more threads the more bandwidth and server space gets used. I would welcome a fresh new idea or discussion but I don't hold my breath one is forthcoming on this topic. Perhaps a new claimant will come forward. AA has been discussed to death and back again.