Discussions about the Imperial Family and European Royalty > Tatiana Nicholaievna

Tatiana in "Nicholas and Alexandra"

(1/40) > >>

Sarastasia:
Heya everyone
I just got the DVD of "Nicholas and Alexandra" for Christmas and I was watching it yesterday. There is a scene whe they are imprisoned in Ekaterinburg, where a guard walks into OTMA's room. I was shocked that Tatiana suddenly revealed her chest to the guard, without any reasoning!  :o
I would have never expected this of her! And I have never heard of such an occurance!!
Does anyone know if any such thing happened? Or are the makers just making things up?... again

Sarastasia

lilavanderhorn:
They were making things up again, in order to show how "deprived" the poor girls were when it came to male companionship.  Frankly I found the whole scene vulgar and repulsive, and should not have been included.  From what we know of Tatiana she would not dream of doing something like this.  A young, very protected and religious girl brought up under the likes of Alexandra would never demean herself this way.

Sarastasia:
I agree! I was really looking forward to a scene with OTMA on their own, and I was really disgusted by it!!
From what we know, she would never do such a thing as that, and she would scold a young lady herself for doing so!
Yes, she became deeply religious so she would definatly never have done this.
In all honesty, I sat through the film, picky holes in it! But it is a very good film... but historical discrepencies annoy me so. I almost flipped when they said that Alexei was born at 8 pounds, when he was really 11 pounds!

Sarastasia

Sarastasia:
Here I have some photos of the scene:
http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d61/SaraFeodorovna/Nicholas%20and%20Alexandra/cef22b8b.jpg
http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d61/SaraFeodorovna/Nicholas%20and%20Alexandra/cap005.jpg
First, Tatiana doesn't want him to be there.
http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d61/SaraFeodorovna/Nicholas%20and%20Alexandra/Tatianasbearing.jpg
Then she shows her chest for an unknown reason...
http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d61/SaraFeodorovna/Nicholas%20and%20Alexandra/3997819f.jpg
OMA stand and watch
http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d61/SaraFeodorovna/Nicholas%20and%20Alexandra/9fc327b5.jpg
Then she becomes really upset, and Olga tries to comforts her.

An accurate depictation of Tatiana? I don't think so...

Margarita Markovna:
I don't think so either....this is almost like the Tatiana-Cleopatra thread.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page