Did AA have an undiagnosed mental illness...

[jeremygaleaz]

According to information I have Gertrude died in the late 1960's not 1995/96.    

That was Felix

[jeremygaleaz]

According to some old posts sent to me by email, this had all been previously discussed, and it turns out that Waltrud gets paid nicely for these interviews, and says things that contradict what Gertrude said in depositions.
So who are we to believe the sister that knew her or the niece that didn't?

Because if you actually read the testimony, translated from an objective source you'd see that what Gertrude said was very favorable to the case of those that wanted to prove AA was indeed FS.

[Grand_Duke_Paul]

That was Felix

I don't think so...

[jeremygaleaz]

I don't think so...

So, bring it on! I have no problem being wrong on subjects, if I am,  show us what you have

[Belochka]

FS's niece Waltraud, gave an interview in which she stated that her aunt often liked to "play princess" even as a small child, pretending not to be related to her other siblings, walking apart from them to church, the market, etc. So what ever it was, the root was there when she was a small child.  

Role playing while pretending you are someone else as a child is not harmful UNLESS a similar game is performed by an adult.

Through the generosity of persuasive personalities stronger than her own, it was easier to accept the new challenges and then emerge with a whole new identity.

This lady got lucky, instead of taking a step down when she was at her most fragile emotional state, the step up offered all the rewards she had always dreamed.

That mental re-adjustment was a behavioral deviation  which became her personal reality. A star performer whose curtain tumbled when DNA appeared on the scene to destroy that well tutored performance.

[jeremygaleaz]

Role playing while pretending you are someone else as a child is not harmful UNLESS a similar game is performed by an adult.

Through the generosity of persuasive personalities stronger than her own, it was easier to accept the new challenges and then emerge with a whole new identity.

This lady got lucky, instead of taking a step down when she was at her most fragile emotional state, the step up offered all the rewards she had always dreamed.

That mental re-adjustment was a behavioral deviation  which became her personal reality. A star performer whose curtain tumbled when DNA appeared on the scene to destroy that well tutored performance.

Very well said.  

Still, I"d bet there was a pretty severe enstrangment from her family.
From what I understand, she received virtually no aid from her family the entire time she was recovering from the shock of the grenade explosion.

In fact, the only aid her caretakers received was a "ration card" issued by the German government. And, it seemed, they continued to use this after FS dissapeared. Hence, their reluctance to report her missing, as their ration card privledges would end.

[Grand_Duke_Paul]

So, bring it on! I have no problem being wrong on subjects, if I am,  show us what you have

You are so anxious to see what everyone else has, without sharing your own sources.  If I am wrong I will also be big enough to admit it, however since you keep quoting this date, what is your source?  

[jeremygaleaz]

You are so anxious to see what everyone else has, without sharing your own sources.  If I am wrong I will also be big enough to admit it, however since you keep quoting this date, what is your source?  

I knew you'd answer this way! However, I asked you  first!:

[catt.sydney]

You are so anxious to see what everyone else has, without sharing your own sources.  If I am wrong I will also be big enough to admit it, however since you keep quoting this date, what is your source?  

GDP
PLEASE let me suggest something...
This brutal refusal to answer civil questions for information is very like the reactions of 'another poster' (NO LONGER HERE)...[hint] and as some posters here expressed serious questions about you and this individual you might try to be a bit less harse in your refusals in the future. It puts you in a bad light.

It has be stated before that "Civility is a Noble Virtue"
Grand Duke?

[Grand_Duke_Paul]

GDP
PLEASE let me suggest something...
This brutal refusal to answer civil questions for information is very like the reactions of 'another poster' (NO LONGER HERE)...[hint] and as some posters here expressed serious questions about you and this individual you might try to be a bit less harse in your refusals in the future. It puts you in a bad light.

It has be stated before that "Civility is a Noble Virtue"
Grand Duke?

Dear Catt,

I am not concerned in the least about the light it puts me with others.  We have gone through the name game before, so who am I now, Greg, Penny, Michael,  Anastasia, FS, AA, Kurth, Schweitzer, or some other unknown poster who has bitten the dust?

So as far as I am concerned you can keep your comments such as this to a PM or between yourselves.
FA & Moderator have warned others about this before and if it keeps up I will bring it to their attention again.

[Annie]

According to some old posts sent to me by email, this had all been previously discussed

   

[Grand_Duke_Paul]

     

Since I put my email address on here you should see the unsolicited emails I have had from former posters in this forum.   At least 30-35.  It is amazing, and the things they had to say about you, very nice. You have many friends.

[Eddie_uk]

Since I put my email address on here you should see the unsolicited emails I have had from former posters in this forum.   At least 30-35.  It is amazing, and the things they had to say about you, very nice. You have many friends.

[Annie]

No, I don't think she ever forgot her 'true self'-

"It's the name of your true self, you've only forgotten!"

"That name no longer has any meaning to me!"

Couldn't resist the SW joke!

Also, a niece doesn't have to know an aunt personally to know the stories. I could write books in vivid detail on people who died before I was born, thanks to family stories.

[Grand_Duke_Paul]

Not mentioning any names, but come on and give us a break here. It is PAINFULLY OBVIOUS YOU ARE NOT NEW.

I was told you would be this way, and at the moment it just amuses me that you spend so much time in such an exercise in futility.   How ever I am not going to play this game with you or your clique on the boards, you have a problem, PM me, otherwise keep it off of the threads.